Our reviews
Reviews from Grubhub
Virginia
Top Reviewer
Mario's is always great. They deliver fast and the driver is super nice. The food is delicious. I love the mozzarella sticks and the grandma pizza. They even make pizzettes for one person (but they're big enough to split honestly - I usually do). Definitely recommend them!
Rachel
Top Reviewer
I've been a fan of Mario's for as long as I've lived in the area (about 16 years now), and I'm so happy to be able to order from them on GrubHub!
The food is always on time, and it's always delicious. Highly recommend the garlic knots - they're the best around!
The food is always on time, and it's always delicious. Highly recommend the garlic knots - they're the best around!
Nate
Top Reviewer
Had great food here on 2 concurrent nights. The chicken noodle soup is fantastic! Also they are pretty quick and on both nights were ahead of the anticipated time. Thanks!
David
Top Reviewer
Never had a bad order from here and I order here often. Always on time or early, and the food is like it was just taken off the stove or oven, excellent. Highly recommend.
Sindy
1 review
I always order the whole wheat chicken Ceasar wrap it's amazing!! And to make it to the delivery minimum I order the mini buffalo chicken rolls they are yummy!
Reviews from Seamless.com
Hector
3 reviews
Our family ordered a Sicilian Pie from Mario's Pizzeria and not only did it come on time but it was great. There was honestly nothing to complain about and Mario's will definitely become a regular at our house.
Richvinder
1 review
the food is delicious and the price is decent too. its not too expensive. great spot if youre feeling some italian food
Aryeh
2 reviews
Love the food, service, everything about this place. Order from here all the time.
Brittany
1 review
Amazing food, super fast delivery, and such nice employees! Five stars!
Larissa
1 review
Food was delivered hot and delicious and on time. Highly recommend!
About us
American, Calzones, Dinner, Italian, Lunch Specials, Pasta, Pizza, Salads, Sandwiches, Soup, Wraps
Today
Delivery: 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Takeout: 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Since the opening of our first store in Oyster Bay over 4 years ago, Mario's Pizzeria has been serving quality food made with the finest ingredients and following 'Old World' traditional recipes. Currently, with eight locations across Long Island, Mario's Pizzeria expands its service to its customers. Mario's Pizzeria of Plainview is located on Long Island's historic Old Country Road and offers high quality food made with the finest ingredients, personalized service, unsurpassed value and the traditions of long ago in today's convenient world.come on in and join us for a memorable dining experience. We look forward to the opportunity to serve you.